I've been fretting recently about how often I notice mothers saying '
Oh, you're such a boy' to their sons. As we know I don't have sons so this is possibly one of those things I should just leave alone ... but, just briefly, I won't.
I don't like gender bias as a rule, and it makes me particularly uncomfortable when people do it to kids. What does 'such a boy' even really mean?
We all know what 'such a girl' means. And that's why I never say it. There's a negative connotation right? An implication of softness, or squeamishness, or (horror) being over-emotional.
I don't say to my girls, when they're dressed all in pink or pushing dolls around in prams or freaking out 'cos they got duck poo on their feet, '
Oh, you're such a girl.' Just as I wouldn't say it to them when they're smashing rocks (ja, all those
pretty rocks ...) or kicking a ball around the lawn or pulling wings off flies.
And when they're being unreasonable, or farting in public, or punching each other I certainly won't say '
Don't be such a boy', although I've had mothers admit to saying the opposite to their sons when they've thought they're being 'girlie'.
Yes, I have been intrigued to see how my youngest girl has embraced dolls and playing 'baby' since she could just crawl, I watch in equal parts fascination and horror as my 5 year old totally falls for the pink marketing so rife out there. No doubt if I had a son I'd be as amazed to observe his undeniably male character traits, and I'm sure I'd be proud of his boisterous bravado, or ability to quietly play Lego for hours (I'm particularly disappointed to never experience that one!), but I like to think I'd never voice his gender specificity to him directly.
I like to think I'm conscious about not engaging in any gender stereo-typing when talking to the girls at all (although out of their earshot I've been known to accuse my husband of 'screaming like a girl' - the spiders in this house are really, really scary!).
But maybe this is a concern for mothers of girls more than those with boys. Maybe this is purely my baggage about the world they're entering and the optimistic belief, like so many mothers before me, that somehow what I instill in my daughters before leaving home will reflect in the world they'll inhabit. That maybe this generation will be the one to experience a different gender paradigm.
Maybe this is all my own hey-sho-wow hope that if we don't pigeon-hole our kids at home they'll be freer to be themselves in the world? Girls can be tough and boys can be soft. Hurling rocks at ducks is not 'being a boy', pretending to change the nappy of the same rock not 'being a girl'.
Maybe our kids can just be kids and deal with all this complex gender crap as it comes, 'cos it will, without any prodding from their mothers.
When discussing this with my husband however, his parting shot was this, '
So what do you think the long term effects of calling them 'disgusting creatures' will be? Because you seem to do that pretty often.'
Oh, oops.